Skip to content
Indian Liberals
Filter:

Tip: search runs across all languages; results are tokenised per-page using the document's lang attribute. Search inside the documents →

essay

INDIA IS GREATER THAN HINDI

A CASE FOR THE CONTINUANCE OF THE ENGLISH LANGUAGE

MATHAI'S PUBLICATIONS · BOMBAY 7

3 pages

Summary

Isaac Mathai’s essay argues that English should continue as India’s common and international language rather than being displaced by Hindi. He presents English as a valuable inheritance of two centuries, linking Indians to accumulated knowledge, science, education, and communication across a country divided by regional languages, religions, and communities. The essay portrays the choice as one affecting future generations and criticizes politicians who, in Mathai’s view, disregard the preferences of educators, universities, parents, and other institutions for short-term political advantage.

Mathai challenges the claim that Hindi represents a national majority, emphasizing that most Indians speak regional languages and that Hindi itself has competing forms, including Sanskritised, Persianised, colloquial, and Urdu varieties. He also makes a practical case: replacing English would make higher education and specialized technical knowledge difficult and costly to produce in regional languages. The essay concludes by connecting English with internationalism and calls for English-language societies and educational centres throughout India. The accompanying covering letter solicits paper or cash contributions for a wider circulation among educators, legislators, municipal councillors, and other public institutions.

Key points

  • English is presented as an inherited resource containing accumulated wisdom, knowledge, and experience.
  • The essay argues that India’s linguistic diversity makes a single Hindi-based national language impractical.
  • Mathai disputes the characterization of Hindi speakers as a majority of India’s population.
  • The text criticizes political efforts to replace English despite support for its continued use among educators and institutions.
  • The essay argues that regional-language higher education would be expensive, difficult to maintain, and quickly outdated in specialized fields.
  • English is defended as a medium of communication across India’s diverse communities and as a bridge to internationalism.
  • The covering letter seeks financial or material support to distribute the essay and promote English-language education.

Metadata and summary are AI-extracted from the source PDF and reviewed for editorial accuracy. The original work is available via the Read PDF tab above (where present); paragraph-level citation inside the PDF is deferred to a future engagement.

Related across the archive