[Letter to Mr C Rajagopalchari]

Summary

In this letter dated 5 April 1970, M. R. Masani writes to C. Rajagopalachari (“Rajaji”) about the continuing controversy over C. C. Desai’s explanation and possible expulsion. Masani encloses Desai’s statement and points Rajagopalachari to press reports in the Gujarati Herald and Janmabhoomi, arguing that Desai had advocated a Gujarati government that would have the support of Indira Gandhi’s government while remaining loyal to the Central Government.

Masani reports that H. M. Patel supports Desai’s expulsion but is seeking a postponement because the present occasion is not “timely.” He warns that the party should first test Indira Gandhi’s position through C. C. Desai before deciding to strike, since any further weakness toward Desai could affect the party’s response. A postscript adds that Baria is seeking further defections so that he can present a list of Assembly members demanding that the session be convened to overthrow the Gujarat Government. The letter is a direct piece of intra-party correspondence concerning party discipline, legislative strategy, and the stability of a state government.

Key points

• Masani discusses the controversy surrounding C. C. Desai’s explanation and possible expulsion.
• He cites Desai’s reported argument for a Gujarat government supported by Indira Gandhi’s government but loyal to the Central Government.
• H. M. Patel is described as supporting expulsion while favouring postponement because the timing is not suitable.
• Masani urges testing Indira Gandhi’s position through Desai before taking decisive action.
• The postscript reports an effort by Baria to secure Assembly defections and demand that the Gujarat Assembly session be convened.
• The letter reflects concerns about party discipline, legislative majorities, and the survival of the Gujarat Government.